广东古代叫什么名字广东古代叫什么( 二 ) _广东古代叫什么

最后，广东还有一大批土著居民，黎族就是其中之一。需要注意的一件重要的事情是越南和中国人，当你进一步区分这两个所谓的“民族”群体有很多重叠的地方和更多的其他部落，他们彼此非常不同，不能区分他们并不意味着他们是一样的，这就像称所有东亚/东南亚人为“中国人” 。

泰：住在新加坡
Vietnam could not have lost Guangdong to China since Guangdong has never been a part of Vietnam. As others have said, rather, Vietnam was a part of Guangdong, before both became part of China.
越南不可能把广东输给中国，因为广东从来就不是越南的一部分。正如其他人所说，越南曾今是广东的一部分，在两者都是中华的一部分的时候。
But I take issue with the answer "Vietnam was part of China for a long time until France annexed it from China".Absolutely wrong. Vietnam has been independent from China since the 10th century, except for a brief 20-year occupation by the Ming Dynasty in the 14th century.
但我对“越南长期以来一直是中国的一部分，直到法国将其从中国吞并”的回答表示异议。绝对错了。越南自10世纪以来一直从中国独立，除了在14世纪被明朝短暂占领了20年。
Ming Dynasty Vietnam did pay homage to China during this period and recognized Chinese suarez (nominally) as a diplomatic means to achieve peace. China is still a bigger and more powerful country. But Vietnam is independent in every aspect of the world. It had its own king, its own court, its own army. It manages its own internal affairs and carries out its own foreign policy.
明朝时期越南在此期间确实向中国致敬，并承认中国的宗主权(名义上)，作为一种实现和平的外交手段。中国仍然是一个更大更强大的国家。但是越南在世界的各个方面都是独立的。它有自己的国王，自己的宫廷，自己的军队。它管理自己的内部事务，执行自己的外交政策。
So historical facts do not support "Vietnam was always part of China until France annexed it from China". Even Chinese historical records do not consider Vietnam a part of China. Rather, it's something whimsical people like to ponder.
所以历史事实并不支持“越南一直是中国的一部分，直到法国把它从中国吞并。”即使是中国的历史记录也不认为越南是中国的一部分。相反，这是一些异想天开的人喜欢思考的问题。

王克里斯
A: I think it depends on your understanding of Vietnam. My answer is yes but no
答:我认为这取决于你对越南的理解，我的回答是既是但也不是
Firstly, The answer is No if Vietnam refers to land or geography as the modern sovereignty state today. The Guangdong region is never the land of Vietnam.
首先，如果越南将土地或地理视为现代主权国家，那么答案是否定的。广东地区从来就不是越南的国土。

Secondly, if you think the concept of Vietnam is the land of all Vietnamese ethnic groups and the hundred ethnic groups of South Vietnam, my answer is yes – Guangdong was the land of Vietnamese ancestors before.